Architectural drawings on a desk

Chapter Nine

Evidence on build routes and studio stakes would test the report’s central findings

The report establishes how many studio companies reach a first external round, and the next question is why some studios do better. Its two strongest comparisons, higher funding rates at studios with their own funds and the follow-on advantage after a first round, could reflect what studios do or which companies they choose to back. Four company records would separate the two, led by each company’s build route and the studio’s stake (Exhibit 39).

Exhibit 39Four company records would test the central findings most directly
Evidence gap What would close it Finding it would test
Company records that would test the central findings
Build or pick A built, co-created or invested tag for every company, defined by who originated the idea, recruited the founders and provided first capital, with the date of studio involvement. Comparing funding rates across the routes, counting only rounds after the studio’s involvement, is the most important test of the structural finding Structural association (Chapter 5), second round advantage (Chapter 3) and bottlenecks (Chapter 7)
Studio stakes The studio’s stake at formation and immediately before and after each company’s first external round Studio ownership (Chapter 5)
Vintage The launch year of every portfolio company, to report funding rates by founding cohort and compare time to first external round with same-cohort startups outside studios, including those yet to raise Pooled headline rate and time to first external round (Chapter 3)
Companies that have not raised A comparison of the 124 funded companies with the 332 without a recorded round by sector, launch year, studio stake and studio capital, with registry checks on which of the 332 still operate Headline rate and survivorship bias (Chapter 3)
Stricter tests of the comparisons
Studio-level inference A studio sample large enough for multilevel models, with studio-level sensitivity tests reported for every clustered comparison Second round advantage (Chapter 3), structural association and visibility gap (Chapter 5)
A comparator at entry Complete cohorts from a defined set of African accelerators, including startups that never raised, measured on the same launch year, external round and window definitions Comparison with startups outside studios (Chapter 3)
Legal availability of the dual entity Whether a separate fund was legally and practically available to each studio in its jurisdiction when it was formed, with the structural comparison repeated within that group Environment explanation for structure (Chapter 5)
Mandate A consistent classification of studios as commercial, impact oriented or blended, separating stated mandate from investment practice, tested against funding rates Structural association (Chapter 5)
Founder access Founder and chief executive gender for every portfolio company, funded or not, and, with studio records and consent, for the founders a studio recruits or declines Founder access (Chapter 6)
Evidence on mechanisms and coverage
Founder and investor evidence Interviews with founders, investors and more studios, checked against transaction records, to locate where rounds stall. None of the eleven bottlenecks yet rests on founder evidence Bottlenecks (Chapter 7)
Investor profiles and leads Profiles of all 451 named investors with cheque size and mandate where available, and founder confirmation of the lead in the 46 multi-investor first rounds whose announcements name none First cheque market (Chapter 4)
North Africa The cross-border hypothesis tested with studios, founders and investors in the North African markets covered, and against startups outside studios in the same markets North African hypothesis (Chapter 5)
Wider coverage Assessment of the five studios profiled only in the Summit Directory, and verified records of the 27 additions shared with directory publishers Coverage of the sample (Chapter 2) and the visibility gap (Chapter 5)

All four company records are covered by the disclosure standard proposed in Chapter 8.

Sources: Africa: The Big Deal and authors’ analysis